Skip to main content

Superhero movies: why can't Hollywood learn?

Superheroes
Had to happen: the much-awaited X-Men 3 came out, and I was determined to see it. I'm a big X-Men fan from the 80's, and comic book fan, overall. I wanted to see this one, and have even had the Konfabulator Widget for it counting down. The preview? Stunning. The clips I've seen? Looked to be the right stuff. A winning franchise, a winning formula right?

As usual, Hollywood grows complacent with their success. X-Men 3, on paper, was great: great action, lots of characters, and a really interesting story line (the government finds a "cure" for mutants; do they want to be cured?). Add in an even bigger budget, Oscar winners, and a huge effects scene. But this time, Brett Ratner directs. What does it add up to? A fun night, but no real winner.

Why can't Hollywood learn? When it comes to superhero films, it's a hard enough balance to suspend disbelief. What have been the elements of the truly successful ones? Think about it: the director, who comes from a proven success in independent film making to give a whole new vision.


In most of the above, the director helped write, cast, and set the visual tone of the film. They come from a world of no rules, so they cast aside preconceptions. X-Men 3? Brett Ratner, who's fame comes from music videos and the Rush Hour Jackie Chan/Chris Tucker vehicles. Yes, he's made some gems (Red Dragon was good, as was After the Sunset), but X-Men 3? The lack of risk showed: all the requisite ingredients, with not a good cook, do not a great meal make.

Contrast that with what was playing on HBO when I came home, Batman Begins. Christopher Nolan, of Memento fame, took a whole new look at Batman and made it an incredible film. When I saw it in the theater, I said it was the only thing that could make Tim Burton's Batman look like the Adam West series: it was that original.

Now we have Ghost Rider coming. Previews look great, but Mark Steven Johnson is directing. I know Daredevil was not a commercial success, but I thought he did a great job with the character, the effects, and the movie...but again, hard to suspend disbelief. And don't get me started on Electra...even though my old classmate wrote it, it was still hard to watch. With Ghost Rider, it's a hard character to bring to the screen. It needs more than just a formulaic director. Why not reach into the indies, and get a director who can tap into the evil contract of this character? I can hope it's good, but...

Hollywood needs to learn: these characters are already bigger than life. Adding more explosions or effects will not make this be the film it needs to be. Look at Bryan Singer's upcoming Superman Returns; that focuses on Superman, the man, not the cape and boots. Get a great innovative director, surround them with a world-class character actor team, and get a script that works. Don't be afraid to risk it; Frank Miller brought comics Batman, Daredevil, and Sin City; when Hollywood had him write Robocop 2, they cut the edgy parts that had made Robocop such a success. When he was given free reign in Sin City, the results were box office gold.

Look, Hollywood: we have endless entertainment choices today. After years of parody and neglect, you are finally focusing of characters and stories ripe for the big screen: superheroes. Do it right, take the risk, and watch it payoff. Don't give us Catwoman or Electra: give us passionate directors who feel the characters, and let them work.

We want to like you; let us.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Loyalty Review: Kohl's Yes2You

 As some of you know, I've spent over 15 years in the customer loyalty space. So, when I come across a new retail loyalty program, I can't help but see the pluses and minuses. After this many years, it's kind of ingrained. Periodically, I'll share my thoughts with you. Today, it's Kohl's turn under the scope. Let's have a look, shall we? I've divided the review up into three sections: what's good about the program, what's bad about the program, and what I'd change about it. That last one has some actual value: I charged hundreds of dollars per hour for loyalty program consulting, and had over a dozen clients, before I moved to JustAnswer FT. But, being a pandemic and all, I'm giving it away for free here. Kohl's, you're welcome. Here we go! The Good Sign up is opt in Seems odd to praise Kohl's for this, but in department store loyalty, this is a rarity, and a smart one. It means the customers who are opted in are already prime

2020 CV19 Lockdown: Winners and Losers

It is said that in any time in history, the winners and losers are determined when a unique set of circumstances arises the requires an unprecedented response. How a company responds to those conditions can often propel them to new heights, or sentence them to an ignominious end. This post is meant to be an ongoing and often updated list of those that may come out of the Great 2020 Covid19 Lockdown as champs...or chumps. Winners Zoom How is it that, with all of the video conferencing choices in the market, a relatively obscure one (and a freemium one, to boot!) ran away with the title? Think of it: you had entrenched competitors like Skype and Facebook, as well as work-focused like Microsoft Teams , Google Hangouts , and Amazon Chime , any one of which had far greater reach than Zoom . Yet Zoom won, to the point that they achieved the exalted state of having their product/platform become a verb ("I'll Zoom you later"). More amazingly, they even continued their gro

The Icarus Effect

This morning's news started with the latest grim proof of overdevelopment in a tough sector: SkyBus Airlines shut down , less than year from when it started. Never heard of Skybus? Not surprising; they chose to focus on trips from Ohio to the West Coast for ridiculously low fares. Yes, you read that right: the airlines' unique niche was that they focused on trips from Ohio . Was air travel such an amazingly profitable business that we needed that much segmentation and focus? Of course not. A year ago, when Skybus was just getting off the ground (har har), fuel costs were at an all time high. United was still in bankruptcy; Delta, a fellow airline with a major hub in Ohio, was just exiting Chapter 11. And yet, "irrational exuberance" led investors like Nationwide Mutual Capital, Huntington Capital Investment Co., and Battelle Services Co. to ignore the obvious signs of risk, and dive into what was a dubious investment. Today, they, and the passengers who were lured by