Skip to main content

TechCrunch is Wrong: The Cost Of Nexus One Freedom

TechCrunch has an article on the new "GooglePhone," the NexusOne, and "why it still matters." In essence, it's been revealed that you can buy it, unlocked to any carrier, for $530. The article makes an attempt to justify that, while the cost is high, it still is amazingly groundbreaking. I could not disagree more. Let's have a look at what the argument is for "why this still matters," and why it's a crock.

Google is supposedly selling this $530 Nexus One completely unlocked. Uh, so what? This is a GSM phone, which means in the US, that vaunted "unlocking" lets you not only use it on T-Mobile (the preferred carrier), but all other US GSM carriers. What's that you say? Who are the vast selection of others? AT&T. That's it. Yep. So, let me get this straight: I can spend nearly twice as much for a phone that I can choose to sign a contract to use...with all of 1 other carrier? Oh, and if I do want to use this with AT&T, I can only use it with their EDGE data network, not even their 3G network? In what world is this good news?

The crux of the argument here is that "wow, it's amazing: you can buy a truly unlocked GSM phone." Guess what? You have been able to: as long as you jailbreak your iPhone. The problem is not that it's unlocked, it's that the US is not Europe: Europe has multiple GSM carriers, all competing for your Euros. As a result, you have real choice in plans, whereas in the US, you don't. Telling me that this "amazing" new development will somehow stimulate carriers is just wishful thinking.

What Google truly needed to do here is to offer this unlocked phone for a nominal fee, or even $0, but build in an ad model. Imagine bringing up the e-mail client in the phone, and Google targeted AdWords float in the notifications bar, a la Gmail. Or a web browser with built in ad space. Or being able to offer Google Talk with targeted audio ads. Google is buying the top advertising system for mobile devices (Admob), so they clearly understand there is money to be made from mobile ads. Hell, how about having to listen to a 10 second ad before your call connected? Would you do that for a $0 Android powered smartphone? You damn well might. Voicemail from Google Voice? Now that is what I would call innovative.

Why wouldn't Google do that? Well, for one, it might rankle the carriers a bit. But if you still had to pay their plans, they'd get past it, especially if it drove adoption. Google certainly has the cash. Perhaps they fear that the open Android architecture would allow easy workarounds? Maybe, but since Google controls that architecture, no one would fault them for setting limits on this hardware. And if a few uberhackers figured out ways around it, it still would not go mainstream, and Google could probably build in some terms of service that allowed them to cut the phone service off if the customer did.

I applaud Google for getting into the space. I like Android. As I said way back in September 2008, "The taskbar at the top of the screen is incredibly smart and intuitive, as is the sync to Google applications." I think Android has progressed dramatically since then. And I want choice: competition breeds innovation, and I would love to see Apple adopt some of Android's strengths, and/or Android to get a true media syncing solution. But the Nexus One had a chance to hit the iPhone where it hurts: the wallet. And Google is balking at taking that shot, with no reason. And if the Nexus One fails to make a big impact, I can see Google walking away, which would be a real shame for the consumer, as well as for their future.


Popular posts from this blog

Loyalty Review: Kohl's Yes2You

 As some of you know, I've spent over 15 years in the customer loyalty space. So, when I come across a new retail loyalty program, I can't help but see the pluses and minuses. After this many years, it's kind of ingrained. Periodically, I'll share my thoughts with you. Today, it's Kohl's turn under the scope. Let's have a look, shall we? I've divided the review up into three sections: what's good about the program, what's bad about the program, and what I'd change about it. That last one has some actual value: I charged hundreds of dollars per hour for loyalty program consulting, and had over a dozen clients, before I moved to JustAnswer FT. But, being a pandemic and all, I'm giving it away for free here. Kohl's, you're welcome. Here we go! The Good Sign up is opt in Seems odd to praise Kohl's for this, but in department store loyalty, this is a rarity, and a smart one. It means the customers who are opted in are already prime

San Diego: Day 1

Coronado Island is home to some of the most tranquil harbors and beautiful Southern California beach land ever. Of course, it's also got the requisite tourist village and some fun restaurants; we ate at a 50's joint, called the Beach-N-Diner : nothing special but HUGE salads. Really loud music they were accommodating enough to turn down so we could all catch up. After filling our stomachs, we headed to the main draw of the island: the Hotel Del Coronado. A sprawling, beautiful wooden hotel, it evokes the '30's sense of splendor. Everything too perfect, with the Pacific as the ideal backdrop. We toured the lobby, then headed to the deck to sit with drinks and take in the scenery. After, we peeked in the courtyard: the architecture is magnificent. Like the Levi Strauss building grafted to an oceanliner. Private decks, soaring palms, and a gazebo. Magnificent. A short drive around Coronado to see the naval installations, then back to the Inn for some respite. Then, dinner.

Revisiting Star Trek: The Next Generation: Season 1

I recently started rewatching Star Trek: The Next Generation from the beginning. I have nothing but fond memories of the original run in the 1980s, given how excited I was for a new Trek series in my lifetime (I had only reruns and the movies to stoke my Trek interest), and it recently occurred to me that, while I diligently consumed every TNG episode, I had not experienced the series since it's original run.  Why did I do this? Well, a few reasons: With the triumphant return of Sir Patrick Stewart to the smaller screen as the venerable Jean Luc Picard , I thought it would be interesting to contrast this version with the previous, and see how far he has come. It would add color to the character, as well as Sir Patrick. Frankly, with the COVID19 lockdown, the series I have binged upon have been intense, dark, and disturbing. Combined with the activity of the world, including insane politics, homicidal police who seem to view people of color as "prey," rather than their ch